Why Highly Capable Women Become Expert Self-Doubters
- Louise Beauchamp
- Jun 16
- 6 min read
A few years ago, I found myself becoming increasingly curious about a question that seemed, on the surface at least, difficult to explain.
Why do some of the most capable women I know spend so much time doubting themselves?
I am not talking about women at the beginning of their careers or women who are genuinely struggling in their roles. I am talking about women with decades of experience, impressive qualifications and significant achievements. Women who lead teams, influence decisions and solve complex problems every day. Women whose competence is rarely questioned by anyone except themselves.
Yet despite all of this evidence, many continue to second-guess their judgement. They hesitate before speaking in meetings. They spend days preparing for presentations they are more than capable of delivering. They seek reassurance for decisions they could easily make independently. They replay conversations long after they have ended and worry about comments that nobody else has even noticed.
The more women I worked with, the more I realised this was not an isolated phenomenon. It was a pattern.
What interested me most was not the self-doubt itself, but the apparent contradiction at its heart. If capability creates confidence, why are some of the most capable women also some of the biggest self-doubters?
The answer, I suspect, lies in the fact that we may have been asking the wrong question all along.
When Evidence Fails to Convince
One of the most striking things about self-doubt is that it often survives in the face of overwhelming evidence.
Most of us assume that confidence grows as competence increases. The logic seems sound. The more experience we gain, the more successful we become and the more expertise we accumulate, the more confident we should feel.
Yet this is not always what happens.
Over the years, I have worked with women who have built impressive careers whilst remaining remarkably reluctant to acknowledge their own capability. A promotion is attributed to good timing. A successful project becomes a matter of luck. Positive feedback is dismissed as kindness rather than taken as an accurate reflection of performance.
I have also met women who continue to pursue qualification after qualification despite capability clearly not being the issue. Their expertise is evident to everyone around them. Their colleagues seek their advice. Their organisations rely on their judgement. Yet they continue searching for one more course, one more certificate or one more piece of evidence that will finally allow them to feel credible.
What fascinates me is that these women are not lacking evidence.
The evidence exists.
The problem is that they do not trust it.
Or perhaps more accurately, they do not trust themselves.
The Difference Between Confidence and Self-Trust
Recently, I was speaking with a woman who repeatedly described her challenge as a lack of confidence.
Each time she used the word, I gently offered an alternative perspective.
Perhaps confidence was not the issue.
Perhaps self-trust was.
Yet despite our conversation, she kept returning to confidence. It was the explanation that felt most familiar to her.
The exchange stayed with me because I think it reflects a wider misunderstanding about the challenges many women face.
Confidence has become the default explanation for almost everything. Women are encouraged to build it, strengthen it and develop more of it. Entire industries have emerged around the promise of helping women become more confident.
But what if confidence is not the problem?
Confidence is often dependent on circumstances. Most people feel confident when they are operating within familiar territory. Confidence rises when things are going well and falls when they are not. It is influenced by context, experience and environment.
Self-trust feels fundamentally different.
Self-trust is the ability to rely on your own judgement even when certainty is unavailable. It is the willingness to make decisions without guarantees and to move forward despite the possibility of getting things wrong. It is the belief that a mistake does not invalidate your competence and that criticism does not automatically mean you are wrong.
A woman with self-trust may still feel nervous before a presentation or uncertain before a difficult conversation. The difference is that she does not interpret those feelings as evidence that she should stop.
The Stories We Create
Human beings are natural meaning-makers.
When information is missing, we create explanations. When feedback is limited, we fill in the gaps. When uncertainty exists, we search for reasons.
Unfortunately, the stories many women tell themselves are rarely generous.
A delayed promotion becomes evidence that they are not ready.
A challenging meeting becomes evidence that they handled something poorly.
A lack of feedback becomes evidence that they are underperforming.
Rarely does the story include alternative possibilities.
Perhaps the manager is overwhelmed.
Perhaps the organisation lacks effective succession planning.
Perhaps development conversations have not been prioritised.
Perhaps visibility is being mistaken for capability.
Instead, many women instinctively turn the spotlight inward. The assumption becomes that there must be something they are missing, some deficiency they have yet to identify or some capability they have yet to acquire.
Over time, these stories become so familiar that they stop feeling like stories.
They begin to feel like facts.
Self-Doubt as a Form of Protection
One of the reasons I believe self-doubt can be so difficult to shift is that it often serves a purpose.
Most discussions frame self-doubt as something entirely negative. Something to be overcome, eliminated or conquered.
Yet when you look more closely, self-doubt can function as a form of protection.
If I question myself first, nobody can accuse me of arrogance.
If I keep my ambitions small, disappointment becomes easier to manage.
If I avoid visibility, I reduce the risk of criticism.
If I remain cautious, I am less likely to attract unwanted attention.
What makes this particularly complex is that self-doubt is rarely attached to a single fear. More often, it sits at the intersection of many different concerns.
There may be fear of judgement, fear of rejection, fear of failure, fear of success, fear of disappointing others or fear of being perceived as difficult. Each fear reinforces the others until self-doubt begins to feel less like a problem and more like a survival strategy.
Not a particularly helpful one.
But an understandable one.
Why Organisations Matter
One of the things that frustrates me about conversations around confidence is how often they focus exclusively on the individual woman.
As though self-doubt exists in isolation from the environment in which she works.
In reality, organisations play a significant role in shaping how people see themselves.
Many workplaces still rely heavily on informal approaches to talent management and succession planning. Visibility often becomes a substitute for potential. Those with the loudest voices are noticed first. Development opportunities are allocated inconsistently. Career pathways remain unclear.
This is not always the result of poor intent. More often, it reflects the reality that many leaders are time poor and stretched across competing priorities. Professional development conversations are delayed. Feedback becomes infrequent. Potential is assumed rather than discussed.
The problem is that when capable people receive little information, they tend to create their own explanations.
And those explanations are not always kind.
The absence of recognition can easily be interpreted as a lack of potential. A lack of feedback becomes evidence of poor performance. Being overlooked becomes proof that someone else is more capable.
The organisation may never have intended to send those messages.
Yet they are received nonetheless.
The Pattern Beneath the Pattern
Perhaps the most important thing I have learned is that self-doubt rarely appears as a single dramatic moment.
It is usually a pattern.
A woman edits her comments before speaking in a meeting.
She spends hours preparing for a presentation she could probably deliver without notes.
She seeks reassurance despite being the expert in the room.
She focuses on how her message will be received rather than whether it needs to be said.
Individually, these behaviours appear insignificant. Collectively, they reveal something much more important.
They reveal a habit of treating her own judgement as less trustworthy than everyone else's.
And perhaps that is the real issue.
Not confidence.
Not competence.
Not capability.
Trust.
A Different Conversation
I sometimes wonder what would happen if we stopped asking women how they could become more confident and started asking a different question.
What would it take for you to trust yourself more?
What would change if you treated your own judgement with the same respect you offer to everyone else?
What would happen if you stopped waiting for certainty before taking action?
These questions feel more interesting to me because they acknowledge something important about being human.
Doubt is normal.
Uncertainty is inevitable.
Even the most successful people experience both.
The goal is not to eliminate self-doubt completely.
The goal is to stop allowing it to have the final say.
Because when I look at the women I most admire, I do not see women who never questioned themselves.
I see women who eventually learned that self-doubt and capability can coexist.
Women who discovered that confidence was never the prerequisite they thought it was.
And women who, despite uncertainty, learned to trust themselves enough to move forward anyway.
Comments